35%: The Rising Tide of Credit Card Surcharges Signals a Shift in Business Power
Thirty-five percent of U.S. businesses are now tacking on surcharges for credit card transactions, according to the J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Merchant Services Satisfaction Survey – a figure that underscores a fundamental shift in the balance of power between merchants and payment processors. While 96% of businesses still accept credit cards, the increasing willingness to impose fees directly on cardholders reveals a growing frustration with the escalating costs of processing those payments, costs that have historically been absorbed by businesses. This isn't merely a trend among small retailers; Erie Events, managing a venue that routinely handles 5,000 customers at a time, has embraced a cashless system to streamline operations and reduce wait times, demonstrating the broader applicability of this strategy.
See the original USA Today story for the full account.
Follow the money: credit card processing fees, typically ranging from 1.5% to 3% per transaction, have steadily increased over the past decade. For Lavery Brewing Co., these fees amounted to a staggering $40,000 in 2025, a burden that directly impacted operating margins. Faced with this reality, owner Jason Lavery opted to implement a 1.75% surcharge plus 20 cents on credit card purchases rather than raising prices across the board, a decision he justified as a way to avoid penalizing cash-paying customers. This choice highlights a key tension: businesses are increasingly squeezed by payment processing costs, yet hesitant to alienate customers with price increases.
The decision to add a surcharge, or even eliminate credit card acceptance entirely, isn't solely about cost savings. At Erie Events, the move to a cashless system, spearheaded by executive director Gus Pine, was driven primarily by the need to improve customer service. Pine noted that handling cash transactions slowed down service at concession stands, a persistent issue highlighted in annual fan surveys. Eliminating cash allowed for a more streamlined buying process, reducing wait times and freeing up staff previously dedicated to counting and depositing up to $50,000 after events. This illustrates how operational efficiency can be a powerful motivator, even outweighing concerns about customer convenience.
Natalya Voyetz, owner of Natalya's Sewing Center, has taken a more extreme approach, refusing to accept credit cards since opening her business in 2014. Voyetz’s strategy, while unconventional, underscores the long-standing frustration with processing fees. She estimates that avoiding these fees has allowed her to maintain a competitive edge, a testament to the enduring appeal of cash-only businesses, particularly in niche markets where customer loyalty is high. Her approach, while not scalable for larger operations, provides a stark contrast to the more nuanced strategies employed by businesses like Lavery Brewing Co. and Erie Events.
Remarkably, despite the shift in payment policies, businesses report minimal customer backlash. Lavery, for instance, hasn't received a single complaint regarding the surcharge, even though it adds roughly 87 cents to an average $29 check. Pine echoed this sentiment, stating that Erie Events has received “even a handful of complaints” about the cashless system, further mitigated by the availability of prepaid Visa cards for those without credit or debit cards. This lack of consumer resistance suggests a growing acceptance, or perhaps indifference, to these fees, potentially due to a broader normalization of transaction costs in the digital economy.
What this means for your wallet: The rise of credit card surcharges isn't an isolated phenomenon; it's a symptom of a larger trend toward increased transparency in pricing and a potential shift in the way consumers perceive transaction costs. Keep an eye on the prevalence of surcharge signage at businesses you frequent, and consider whether the convenience of credit card usage outweighs the added cost. Will the increasing adoption of surcharge policies lead to a broader re-evaluation of payment methods, or will consumers continue to prioritize convenience over cost, even as those costs rise?
